Embracing ESG: The Path to Sustainable Shipping

 

• 
•  

Introduction

In recent years, Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) factors have become increasingly important across industries worldwide. One sector that has faced significant scrutiny is shipping, given its substantial environmental impact and involvement in global trade. However, the shipping industry is now recognizing the need to adopt sustainable practices and integrate ESG principles into its operations. This article explores the significance of ESG in shipping and highlights the transformative potential it holds for the industry.

What is the regulation framework of ESG

ESG, which stands for Environmental, Social, and Governance, refers to a set of criteria used to assess the sustainability and ethical impact of an investment or business. While there is no singular regulatory framework specifically dedicated to ESG, several regulations and guidelines exist that touch upon various aspects of ESG considerations. These regulations are implemented at national, regional, and international levels. Here are some key elements of the regulatory framework related to ESG:

National Regulations:

Many countries have introduced or are in the process of implementing regulations related to ESG. These regulations can vary significantly from one
country to another. Some countries may require mandatory reporting of ESG-related information by companies, while others may have voluntary frameworks or industry-specific guidelines. For example, the European Union has introduced the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) and the Non-Financial Reporting Directive (NFRD), which aim to standardize ESG disclosure and reporting requirements.

Stock Exchange Requirements:

Stock exchanges in various countries have implemented listing requirements related to ESG. These requirements may include disclosing ESG-related information, adhering to specific ESG reporting standards, or complying with sustainability- related guidelines. Examples include the Sustainability Reporting Guidelines issued by the London Stock Exchange and the Nasdaq Sustainable Bond Network.

International Guidelines:

Several international organizations have issued guidelines and frameworks that promote ESG considerations. The United Nations Global Compact, for instance, provides principles for businesses to align their strategies and operations with universal principles on human rights, labor, environment, and anti-corruption. The Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD), established by the Financial Stability Board (FSB), has developed recommendations for consistent climate-related financial disclosures.

Stewardship Codes:

Some countries have introduced stewardship codes that outline the responsibilities of institutional investors in considering ESG factors. These codes encourage
investors to engage with companies on ESG issues and exercise their voting rights. Examples include the UK Stewardship Code and the Japan Stewardship Code.

Fiduciary Duties:

Regulatory bodies in various jurisdictions have emphasized the integration of ESG factors into fiduciary duties. This means that institutional investors, asset managers, and pension funds should consider material ESG risks and opportunities in their investment decision-making processes. These expectations help promote the long-term sustainability of investments.

It's important to note that the regulatory landscape for ESG is evolving rapidly, and new regulations and guidelines are being introduced regularly. Therefore, it's essential for businesses, investors, and other stakeholders to stay informed about the specific requirements and obligations in their respective jurisdictions.

What’s the difference between ESG and sustainability?
ESG and sustainability are sometimes used interchangeably, but there are some notable differences.

- Generally speaking, sustainability refers to a company’s relationship to the environment, where ESG extends that relationship to social responsibility and corruption.

- ESG is an external investment framework, or a form of metrics, that helps companies communicate their initiatives and investors assess the company’s performance and risk. On the other hand, sustainability is seen as an internal framework that guides the organization’s capital investments. In other words, sustainability is the motivation, ESG is the reported outcome.

- Since ESG is a reporting framework, it is more relevant to publicly traded companies looking to attract and inform investors or any other business looking to attract financing.

What’s the difference between ESG and CSR?
ESG aspires to be a set of disclosure standards that companies complete to communicate sustainability initiatives. Stakeholders, like investors, use ESG reports to screen their investments. Corporate social responsibility (CSR) is a business model where a company’s activities enhance the world around them.

(E) Environmental Impact

The shipping industry has long been associated with high levels of pollution and greenhouse gas emissions. It is responsible for approximately 2-3% of global CO2 emissions, contributing significantly to climate change. Additionally, maritime activities generate other forms of pollution, such as sulfur oxide (SOx) and nitrogen oxide (NOx) emissions, as well as the discharge of ballast water, which can harm marine ecosystems. However, the industry is now making strides to reduce its environmental impact through various initiatives. One of the key drivers of change is the International Maritime Organization (IMO) strategy to
reduce greenhouse gas emissions by at least 50% by 2050 compared to 2008 levels. To address these environmental challenges, shipping companies are now embracing sustainable solutions. Adoption of cleaner fuels like liquefied natural gas (LNG) and biofuels, along with the implementation of energy-efficient technologies and practices, are reducing the industry's carbon footprint. The development of hybrid and electric vessels, as well as investments in renewable energy sources like wind propulsion, are promising steps toward decarbonizing the shipping industry. Furthermore, the adoption of cleaner technologies such
as exhaust gas cleaning systems (scrubbers) and the use of shore power when berthed help reduce air pollution in port areas. Additionally, ballast water management systems are being implemented to prevent the introduction of invasive species into marine ecosystems. These environmental initiatives not only contribute to mitigating climate change but also align with regulatory requirements and enhance a company's ESG performance.

(S) Social Responsibility

ESG in shipping goes beyond environmental concerns and encompasses social factors as well. The shipping industry heavily relies on seafarers, who face numerous challenges related to working conditions, mental health, and labor rights. Recognizing the importance of seafarers welfare, shipping companies are increasingly taking steps to improve their social responsibility practices. Efforts are being made to ensure fair and decent working conditions, including proper training, competitive wages, and access to essential amenities on board. Companies are also addressing mental health concerns by implementing support programs and offering counseling services to seafarers.

Inclusivity and diversity are gaining prominence as well, with shipping companies actively promoting gender equality and providing equal opportunities for all individuals regardless of their background. Encouraging a diverse and inclusive workforce not only enhances the overall well-being of seafarers but also fosters innovation, creativity, and resilience within the industry.

(G) Governance and Transparency

The ''G'' in ESG emphasizes the importance of good governance and transparency Sound governance practices are crucial in ensuring the responsible and sustainable operation of shipping companies. Transparent reporting and adherence to ethical standards are central to building trust among investors and stakeholders.

Companies are increasingly disclosing their environmental impact, sustainability goals, and progress towards meeting them. This allows stakeholders to evaluate the company's commitment to sustainable practices and hold them accountable for their actions.

Furthermore, robust governance frameworks within shipping companies promote ethical behavior and prevent corruption and bribery. Implementing comprehensive codes of conduct, whistleblower policies, and anti-corruption measures are essential steps towards improving governance practices and mitigating reputational risks.

In recent years, various frameworks and guidelines, such as the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) and the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB), have emerged to provide standardized ESG reporting. Adhering to these frameworks enables shipping companies to better assess and communicate their sustainability efforts, facilitating comparisons and benchmarking within the industry.

Benefits and Future Outlook

Embracing ESG in shipping brings numerous benefits. Firstly, it helps shipping companies mitigate risks associated with stricter regulations and potential reputational damage. As governments and international bodies increasingly focus on sustainability, businesses that proactively adopt ESG practices are better positioned to adapt and thrive.

Secondly, integrating ESG principles can drive innovation and efficiency in the shipping sector. Investments in cleaner technologies and alternative fuels not only reduce environmental impact but also enhance operational efficiency, potentially lowering costs in the long run.

Lastly, embracing sustainable practices improves the industry's public perception and attractiveness to investors. With the growing emphasis on responsible investment, companies that demonstrate a commitment to ESG principles are more likely to access capital and secure partnerships with sustainability-focused stakeholders.

What is ESG reporting in the shipping industry?

In the maritime world, similar to other industries, ESG reporting covers topics such as recycling, greenhouse gas emissions, other pollutants to air, ecological impacts, business ethics, employee health and safety, as well as accident and safety management.

ESG reports and sustainability reports aim to disclose performance on parameters within all three areas that are important for the company’s operation. The reporting serves to satisfy stakeholders’ demands for transparency on corporate responsibility issues. It also conveys that the company has policies, initiatives and strategies in place to manage the ESG risks and opportunities.

How to successfully bring ESG reporting to life in shipping companies

Reporting relevant ESG data to stakeholders is a time-consuming and challenging task for many shipping companies these days. How do you show your stakeholders that you have control of your ESG risks, and how do you find the right KPIs and provide trustworthy data? Learn about effective ESG reporting in our interview.

ESG is not only about compliance. It is very much about creating trust in your stakeholders, Particularly for cargo owners and charters.The Shipping companies need to control and report on their ESG performance. Regulators, banks, insurers and investors are focusing more and more on managing ESG risks, forcing the maritime industry to show that they have control of their ESG risk exposure.

Dialogues with stakeholders and an ESG materiality assessment help to fully develop that understanding. The focus questions to be elaborated are: What is important for the company and why? Once you know this, you can identify what is already managed in your existing processes and corporate culture and what adjustments or additional measures you need to establish. Then existing processes need to be mapped into the ESG context and determine what KPIs are relevant to show to the important ESG stakeholders.

Shipping is a heavily regulated industry. We have DCS and MRV reporting, we have SEEMP III plans, we have BWMC, MLC, safety management procedures and many more. This is an advantage when it comes to managing ESG risks. The challenge is to link existing processes, performance and KPIs into an ESG context that shows how the processes help to manage identified ESG risk exposures. In many cases, this may require some adjustments to existing processes and procedures, but you do not need to start from scratch. IMO compliance regulations like BWMC, DCS/MRV, SEEMP III and CII contribute to the E, but also think of what actions already contribute to the social aspect (S) and how to best monitor them (G).

ESG performance data is becoming part of the financial and commercial processes in shipping. This puts additional requirements on the accuracy and trust in the data. Going forward, errors in the reported data can have negative financial and commercial implications. Data trust is important and verification of the most important ESG KPIs is becoming increasingly important.

To avoid overburdening crew and shore personnel, data should be collected once and used multiple times for various stakeholders. The most obvious example is greenhouse gas emissions from vessels. Collecting and verifying vessel emission data on a daily basis creates the foundation for multiple stakeholder reporting including: Cargo owners: Sea Cargo Charter; contract performance (ref new BIMCO ETS and CII clause) - IMO DCS/CII performance - EU ETS and MRV plus other MRV reporting schemes (e.g. UK MRV) - Poseidon for insurance and bank stakeholders. However, in the coming years, sustainability reporting regulations like the EU’s Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) will require more structured sustainability reporting. The upcoming SEEMP III requirements also show how you are managing decarbonization risks. By putting a little extra effort into elaborating the energy efficiency management plan, preferably also looking beyond the required three years ahead, you will build trust in stakeholders such as cargo owners, shareholders, investors and banks. They want to understand how the company is prepared for the future. This can be a competitive advantage going forward.

What do ESG reports of a shipping company include
ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) reports of a shipping company typically include detailed information about the company's environmental impact, social initiatives, and corporate governance practices. Here are some common components you might find in an ESG report for a shipping company:

Environmental Performance:

Emissions: Details on greenhouse gas emissions, including carbon dioxide (CO2), sulfur dioxide (SO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter.

Energy Efficiency: Information on energy consumption and efficiency measures implemented to reduce fuel usage and emissions.

Alternative Fuels: If applicable, the company may highlight efforts to transition to cleaner fuels such as liquefied natural gas (LNG), biofuels, or hydrogen. Waste

Management: Discussion of waste reduction strategies, recycling efforts, and proper disposal of hazardous materials.

Biodiversity: If relevant, information on steps taken to protect marine ecosystems and minimize the impact on marine life.

Social Responsibility

Employee Welfare: Details on initiatives related to employee health and safety, training and development programs, diversity and inclusion efforts, and labor rights.

Community Engagement: Information on the company's involvement in local communities, including partnerships with non-profit organizations, social projects, and philanthropic activities.

Supply Chain: Discussion of responsible sourcing practices, efforts to ensure fair labor standards and ethical conduct across the supply chain, and human rights considerations.

Governance and Ethics

Board Structure: Information about the composition and independence of the company's board of directors, including diversity, expertise, and board committees.

Ethics and Compliance: Details on the company's code of conduct, anti-corruption policies, and measures to ensure compliance with relevant laws and regulations.

Risk Management: Discussion of the company's approach to identifying and managing risks, including environmental and social risks.
Transparency and Reporting: Information on the company's reporting practices, disclosure standards, and engagement with stakeholders.

It's important to note that the specific content and level of detail in an ESG report can vary between companies. Some companies may follow established reporting frameworks, such as the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) or the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB), to provide standardized and comparable information.